The Supreme Court of India has advised married Hindu women without children to create a will to prevent inheritance disputes between their parents and in-laws. Learn about the Court’s observations, the role of Section 15(1) of the Hindu Succession Act, and why making a will is crucial.
Introduction
In a significant observation aimed at reducing inheritance-related conflicts, the Supreme Court of India recently urged married Hindu women—particularly those without children—to prepare a will. The Court highlighted that doing so would help prevent potential disputes between a woman’s parental family and her in-laws after her death.
This important advisory came while the Court was hearing a petition questioning the constitutional validity of certain succession provisions under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
Why the Supreme Court Issued This Advisory
A Bench comprising Justice BV Nagarathna and Justice R Mahadevan was examining a petition filed by a woman advocate who challenged parts of the Hindu Succession Act. During the hearing, the Bench emphasized the importance of women proactively safeguarding their self-acquired property.
The Court stated:
Women—especially Hindu women who may fall under the scope of Section 15(1) of the Act—should take immediate steps to create a will. This helps secure their interests and prevents unnecessary litigation after their death.
Understanding the Legal Context
Section 15(1) of the Hindu Succession Act
Under the current law, if a Hindu woman dies without leaving a will and has no children, her property typically passes to the heirs of her husband. This often leads to disputes between her parents and in-laws.
Why the Law Was Challenged
- The petition filed under Article 32 sought the striking down of Section 15(1)(b).
- It argued that the provision violates Article 14 (Right to Equality) and Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty).
However, the Supreme Court declined to rule on the validity of the provision, leaving the issue open for future consideration. According to reports, including Livelaw, the Bench felt that such questions must be raised by affected individuals.
Mediation Made Mandatory Before Litigation
The Court also laid down an important procedural guideline:
- If a Hindu woman dies intestate (without a will), and her parents or their heirs claim her property, they must first undergo pre-litigation mediation.
- Any settlement reached in mediation will hold the same value as a court decree.
This step aims to reduce the burden on courts and encourage amicable resolution of inheritance disputes.
Government’s Response
Additional Solicitor General K. M. Nataraj, appearing for the Union Government, opposed the petition and submitted that the issue should be brought by parties personally impacted by the provision rather than through a public interest litigation (PIL).
Why Making a Will Matters
The Supreme Court’s advisory reinforces an important legal takeaway for Hindu women:
- A registered will ensures clarity about property rights after death
- It helps avoid family disputes
- It secures the woman’s intention regarding her self-acquired property
- It prevents the automatic application of Section 15(1), which may not always reflect her wishes
Conclusion
The Supreme Court’s remarks highlight the importance of legal awareness among Hindu women regarding inheritance laws. By creating a will in accordance with Section 30 of the Hindu Succession Act and the Indian Succession Act, women can ensure that their property is distributed according to their wishes and prevent prolonged legal battles among surviving family members.
Registered vs. Unregistered Will in India: Why Registering a Will Matters
